The importance of religious diversity for religious disagreement. Are the perspectives of believer and philosopher so different?
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.21146/2587-683X-2019-3-2-60-75Keywords:
Religious disagreement, religious diversity, rationality of religious belief, philosophical and religious attitudes, functions of religionAbstract
The fact of religious diversity is vital for the philosopher of religion but also, to some extent, for the believer of a given faith. It takes place in such a dimension in which the views of a given believer or the meaning of the practice of a given religion presupposes the truthfulness of specific claims concerning a given religion or the beliefs included in it. If now on the part of the philosopher of religion or the followers of another religion, there is a direct or indirect challenge to such a key proposition, religious disagreement with epistemic dimension is involved. At the same time, it is not the case that any religious diversity is a case of epistemically significant religious dissent. The paper, by distinguishing different aspects of religions and functions performed by religion, tries to show in which situations religious diversification leads to religious disagreement. Both the follower of religion and the philosopher of religion can and should seek the truth in matters of crucial importance to religion. The difference is that the follower of a given religion is more interested in the salvific and practical functions of religion, along with the associated sense of value and meaningfulness of life and, to a lesser degree, the theoretical certainty that her religion is correct at crucial points. On the other hand, the achievement of ‘the soteriological’ purpose of religion based on false belief is impossible, just as the meaningfulness of life 'based on the sand and not on the rock’. It is because the false foundation is devoid of higher value. That is why there is a community of a philosopher of religion and a follower of a given religion to search for the truth of it.Downloads
Published
2019-12-31
Issue
Section
CONTEMPORARY DISCOURSES
How to Cite
The importance of religious diversity for religious disagreement. Are the perspectives of believer and philosopher so different?. (2019). Philosophy of Religion: Analytic Researches, 3(2), 60-75. https://doi.org/10.21146/2587-683X-2019-3-2-60-75